View videos, articles, presentations, research papers, and other resources of interest to STEM Teacher Leaders.

classroom materials
Classroom Material

A New Twist on DNA Extraction

Jeanne Ting Chowning
Regina Wu
Caren Brinkema
Wendy Davis Crocker
Krystal Bass
Debbie Lazerte
Published In
The Science Teacher
Published Date
February 2019
Grade Level
High School
Subject Area



Argumentation is a key scientific practice and a central social and cultural process contributing to the generation, evaluation, and application of new scientific knowledge. As scientists develop arguments and construct knowledge claims, they clarify their own position, attempt to persuade others, and critique and evaluate competing claims. This paper describes the redesign of a common biology lab activity to foreground the roles argumentative critique and collaborative talk play in professional science communities for students. Tasked with designing their own protocols for strawberry DNA extraction, students use their knowledge of cell structure and a list of materials provided to create and test their group’s procedure. After obtaining results, a “lab meeting” is held in which each group presents their protocol, rationale, and results. Then, the students compare procedural details in order to collaboratively redesign a new protocol based on the data provided by each group. These discussions contextualize argumentation within an investigative setting and highlight the importance of questioning, skepticism, and critique. In classroom trials, students reported growth in both their knowledge of the process of DNA extraction and in their ability to use evidence to support ideas about designing and conducting an experiment.